Fork me on GitHub

Opened 10 years ago

Closed 10 years ago

#299 closed Bug (fixed)

Spurious high energy jets

Reported by: Jamie Owned by:
Priority: critical Milestone:
Component: Delphes code Version: Delphes 3
Keywords: Cc:

Description

Hi,

I'm analysing some sherpa events with Delphes and I get some events with extremely high energy. Mostly these have high pz but some also lead to high pt values. By high energy, I mean far bigger than the cms of the collisions.

I have also run exactly the same events through Rivet and see no issues. Examining the HepMC file does not help either.

I am running the latest version (3.1.2) and the ATLAS detector card.

Many thanks,
Jamie

Change History (11)

comment:1 by Michele Selvaggi, 10 years ago

Hi Jamie,

can you attach here a small HepMC file for which you obtain this issue?
I might be that there is an issue with the units used in the HepMc format you are using.

Michele

comment:2 by Jamie, 10 years ago

I don't think this is the issue because using the default setup, the problem is not reproducible, i.e the events with strange momenta happen randomly (and also rarely). In addition, apart from the spurious events, the distributions look ok.

I will try to find an event and random seed combination that reproduces the problem for you.

Many thanks,
Jamie

comment:3 by Jamie, 10 years ago

Hi Michele,

Ok, I think it's a lost cause trying to do this with a small event sample.

I've uploaded the hepmc and root file after Delphes to:

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/1gaztb5dy798fy1/AAAk4G6FV6bg_jUl9bkFd-rha

In the root file, Event 19506 has a jet with energy 9104 GeV (but I have seen much higher with bigger samples).

Cheers,
Jamie

comment:4 by Jamie, 10 years ago

Hi Michele,

After more investigation, I can reproduce this fully with Herwig++ as well. I've simply taken the default t tbar run card and roughly 1 in 10000 events contain a jet with energy > 10TeV (for 13TeV cms). In the first 100000 event run I did, there is a jet with 17TeV.

Many thanks,
Jamie

comment:5 by Jamie, 10 years ago

I should also add that Rivet fails to find any of these jets.

comment:6 by Jamie, 10 years ago

Hi Michele,

Sorry for the continued spam but I can also reproduce this with the Madgraph-Pythia chain. I get similar results for t tbar production as with Herwig.

To me, it looks like something goes wrong with the smearing of forward jets.

Cheers,
Jamie

comment:7 by Jamie, 10 years ago

Hi Michele,

The factor 0.94202 for the forward HCAL resolution seems really high to me. This essentially means that the smearing of the jet is as large as the jet energy itself unless I have mis-interpreted how things work.

Are you sure this is not supposed to be 0.094202?

Cheers,
Jamie

Last edited 10 years ago by Jamie (previous) (diff)

comment:8 by Jamie, 10 years ago

Priority: minorcritical

comment:9 by Michele Selvaggi, 10 years ago

Hi Jamie,

sorry for the very late reply, most of us were offline in the last 3 weeks.
It seems you are right indeed, the constant energy resolution term cannot be ~ 100%.
The resolution has now been corrected in svn. It will be included in a further release.

Thanks for spotting this!

Meanwhile, can you please check that with 0.09420 you don't get spurious jets anymore?

Michele

comment:10 by Jamie, 10 years ago

Hi Michele,

No worries at all. If I change this to 0.09420 then the problem goes away.

Many thanks,
Jamie

comment:11 by Keith Pedersen, 10 years ago

Resolution: fixed
Status: newclosed
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.