Fork me on GitHub

Version 2 (modified by cp3-support, 11 years ago) ( diff )

--

Section 5

The suggestion is to remove this section altogether. It is not detailed enough to be useful to a potential user (in contrast to a user manual), there is also not enough information to understand how things are truly implemented, but it still contains details irrelevant for a publication in JHEP.

PAGE 11

Figure 1 is a striking illustration of the previous comment. This diagram is both too detailed for a JHEP publication, but too simplistic and not readable.

For example:

  • there is no mention of PF, which is an important addition in DELPHES3
  • there is no mention of PU subtraction, another important addition in DELPHES3,
  • the workflow is neither specific and accurate
  • the figure is cut on its right part
  • the caption lacks a complete discussion
Note: See TracWiki for help on using the wiki.