Here is a wishlist for a common !FastSim framework: (points 3-8 has been found to be indispensable to implement [wiki:WorkBook/LibraryInterface prototype of the modular Delphes library]) 1. (optional, lowest priority) ROOT Independence (for example, using some classes from CLHEP and Boost.Python for factories, config. file, etc) 2. (optional) config. file independence (specifying only in-memory representation and access methods) 3. Module factory that creates modules instances at run-time '''by name''' With ROOT it's just {{{gROOT->GetClass(moduleClassName)->New()}}} http://root.cern.ch/root/html/TClass.html Poco has {{{DynamicFactory}}} class http://pocoproject.org/docs/Poco.DynamicFactory.html The simplest solution without ROOT would be {{{ BaseModuleClass* moduleFactory(string const &name) { if(name == "Module1") { return new Module1; } else if(name == "Module2") { return new Module2; } return NULL; } }}} 4. Memory manager that minimizes the amount of memory allocations and that creates/destroys/clears all data collections used by other services and modules (see ROOT {{{TClonesArray}}}, {{{ExRootFactory}}}, Boost Pool). It also clears all data collections produced by other services and modules between events in the event loop. http://root.cern.ch/root/html/TClonesArray.html https://server06.fynu.ucl.ac.be/projects/ExRootAnalysis/browser/trunk/ExRootAnalysis/ExRootFactory.h http://gameprogrammingpatterns.com/object-pool.html http://www.boost.org/doc/libs/1_47_0/libs/pool/doc/concepts.html 5. Central configuration manager that stores all parameters for all modules and that provides access '''by name''' to these parameters ({{{getDouble(name, defaultValue)}}}, {{{getDouble("JetFinder/MinPT", 10.0)}}}). It also should provide access to hierarchical structures with variable dimensions for each entry (like for example {{{map< double, set< double > >}}}) {{{ CaloBins ( ( ( etaEdge1 etaEdge2 ) ( phiEdge1 phiEdge2 phiEdge3 ) ) ( etaEdge3 ( phiEdge4 phiEdge5 phiEdge6 phiEdge7 phiEdge8 ) ) ) }}} 6. Data manager that provides access '''by name''' to all data collections created by other services and modules (see {{{fwlite::Handle::getByLabel(event, label)}}} in CMSSW or {{{TFolder}}} in ROOT) https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/CMSPublic/WorkBookFWLiteEventLoop http://cmssdt.cern.ch/SDT/doxygen/CMSSW_5_3_2/doc/html/d1/dd2/classfwlite_1_1Handle.html http://root.cern.ch/download/doc/ROOTUsersGuideHTML/ch10.html http://root.cern.ch/root/html/TFolder.html 7. Universal object that could represent all physics objects (particles, tracks, calorimeter towers, jets) with possibility to add user defined information (see !FastJet {{{PseudoJet}}} & {{{UserInfoBase}}} classes, CMS PAT {{{UserData}}}, {{{ExRootCandidate}}}) With ROOT, user defined information can be implemented quite easily {{{ class ExRootCandidate { ... private: map< const TClass*, TObject* > fInfoMap }; //------------------------------------------------------------------------------ TObject *ExRootCandidate::GetInfo(const TClass *cl) { map::const_iterator it = fInfoMap.find(cl); return (it != fInfoMap.end() ? it->second : 0); } //------------------------------------------------------------------------------ void ExRootCandidate::SetInfo(TObject *info) { fInfoMap[info->IsA()] = info; } }}} https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/CMSPublic/SWGuidePATUserData http://fastjet.fr/repo/doxygen-3.0.2/classfastjet_1_1PseudoJet.html http://fastjet.fr/repo/doxygen-3.0.2/classfastjet_1_1PseudoJet_1_1UserInfoBase.html https://server06.fynu.ucl.ac.be/projects/ExRootAnalysis/browser/trunk/ExRootAnalysis/ExRootCandidate.h 8. Modules that consume and produce collections of universal objects (see ROOT {{{TTask}}} & {{{TFolder}}}) http://root.cern.ch/download/doc/ROOTUsersGuideHTML/ch10.html http://root.cern.ch/root/html/TTask.html http://root.cern.ch/root/html/TFolder.html